Poe’s Non-Fiction and Literary Rivalries

Today, we know Edgar Allan Poe as one of the seminal authors of the Gothic genre, so it may surprise readers of “The Raven” and “The Tell-Tale Heart” to learn that he made his living not as a writer of poems and tales, but as an editor for a number of magazines. His non-fiction, particularly his reviews and essays, garnered a grudging respect from the literary community—and earned him a few rivals, too, whose criticism of his work and character followed him to the grave.

His first non-fiction pieces appeared in 1835, in the Southern Literary Messenger. The magazine’s owner, Thomas W. White, hired him as an editor, a post that he retained for two years. The experience was evidently so formative that in 1840, three years after he vacated the editorship, he issued a prospectus for Penn Magazine, “which should retain some of the chief features of that Journal [the Messenger],” but which would allow him greater editorial freedom.

The Daily Chronicle and General Advertiser, October 16, 1840. Contains prospectus for Edgar Allan Poe’s Penn Magazine, back page, fourth column. From the Susan Jaffe Tane Collection.

A lack of funds ultimately prevented Penn Magazine from coming to fruition; however, Poe continued to publish his non-fiction in such periodicals as the Saturday Evening Post and Graham’s Magazine. Around the same time, he was contracted by Godey’s Lady’s Book to produce profiles of New York intellectuals for a five-part series called “The Literati of New York City.” His work for Godey’s, in particular, suggests an outsider’s attempt to break into the “insiders only” literary world.

Edgar Allan Poe, “Marginalia.” Graham’s Magazine, November 1846. From the Susan Jaffe Tane Collection.
Edgar Allan Poe, “The Literati of New York City, No. V.” Godey’s Lady’s Book, September 1846. From the Susan Jaffe Tane Collection.

Poe’s reviews and essays gained him a reputation as a difficult critic and spawned several rivalries. Most notably, he found an adversary in the editor Rufus Wilmot Griswold, when he wrote an unenthusiastic review of Griswold’s The Poets and Poetry of America for The Boston Miscellany of Literature and Fashion.

Edgar Allan Poe, review of The Poets and Poetry of America, edited by Rufus Wilmot Griswold. The Boston Miscellany of Literature and Fashion, November 1842. From the Susan Jaffe Tane Collection.

The two battled back and forth for years, and after Poe’s death, Griswold published a cutting obituary in the New-York Daily Tribune under the pseudonym Ludwig. He claimed that “few [would] be grieved” by Poe’s passing, and that “the regrets for his death [would] be suggested principally by the consideration that in him literary art […] lost one of its most brilliant but erratic stars.” He was not finished: In 1850, he released “Memoir of an Author,” in which he accused Poe of recklessness, blackmail, and desertion of his military post. Griswold went so far as to falsify letters to corroborate his reports—all because of a negative review that he had received several years earlier.

New-York Daily Tribune, October 9, 1849. Contains Ludwig [Rufus Wilmot Griswold], “Death of Edgar A. Poe,” back page, third column. From the Susan Jaffe Tane Collection.
Rufus Wilmot Griswold, “Memoir.” The Works of the Late Edgar Allan Poe: With Notices of His Life and Genius, volume III, edited by Rufus Wilmot Griswold. New York: J. S. Redfield, 1850. From the Susan Jaffe Tane Collection

Poe’s non-fiction, and the animosity that it sometimes engendered, heavily influenced his image. For nearly twenty-five years, the public’s knowledge of Poe was drawn from the fictitious “Memoir,” and it took many years after that still for his reputation to improve. Although we may not be as familiar with his reviews and notices as we are with his poems and tales, these pieces contributed, in one way or another, to much of the mythology surrounding Poe.


  1. The Edgar Allan Poe Society of Baltimore. The Life and Writings of Edgar Allan Poe, 1997. http://www.eapoe.org/index.htm. Accessed 23 Feb. 2017.
  2. The Enigmatic Edgar A. Poe in Baltimore and Beyond: Selections from the Susan Jaffe Tane Collection. Johns Hopkins University, 2017. http://exhibits.library.jhu.edu/exhibits/show/enigmatic-edgar. Accessed 23 Feb. 2017.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s